eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.
CommuniGate Systems CommuniGate Pro Real-Time Collaboration 4.3 is the most well-balanced messaging solution eWEEK Labs tested. It has broad hardware and operating system support; good management tools; support for third-party anti-spam and anti-virus applications; and, last but not least, good groupware tools.
Click here to read the full review of CommuniGate Pro Real-Time Collaboration.
2
CommuniGate Systems CommuniGate Pro Real-Time Collaboration 4.3 is the most well-balanced messaging solution eWEEK Labs tested. It has broad hardware and operating system support; good management tools; support for third-party anti-spam and anti-virus applications; and, last but not least, good groupware tools.
Pricing for CommuniGate Pro starts at $22 per user for the base version of the software. Adding clustering capabilities significantly jacks up the price—to $28 per user for 2,500 users—but none of the other products we tested offers this capability.
During tests, we found that CommuniGate Pro provided an Outlook experience similar to what we would find with Exchange. We could easily manage group calendar and scheduling functions, as well as create and manage groups, discussions and shared folders.
Because CommuniGate Pro stores message, calendar, task and contact information separately, it supports a wider range of clients, including Apple Computer Inc.s iCal. This gives administrators a little more flexibility when it comes to backing up and restoring data than they would have with groupware servers that consolidate this data in a single database. For example, administrators will be able to restore a corrupted calendar file without overwriting a users mail file.
CommuniGate Pro has good systems management and security features. We liked that the connector can be installed remotely from the server and is self-updating. The connector also supports SSL (Secure Sockets Layer)/TLS (Transport Layer Security) as well as secure authentication, so companies could give users remote access without having to run a VPN.
Threat prevention includes support for plug-ins from anti-virus vendors Kaspersky Labs, Sophos plc. and McAfee Inc. On the anti-spam side, CommuniGate Pro supports Mailshell Inc.s SpamCatcher Engine. CommuniGate Pro is extensible through an open API. In addition to several vendors of threat prevention plug-ins, VOIP (voice over IP) vendors such as Grand Central Networks Inc. have used this API to integrate voice solutions.
CommuniGate Pro supports a broad range of server hardware, including x86-based systems, Apples PowerPC-based servers, IBMs S/390 and AS/400, and Sun Microsystems Inc.s SPARC-based systems. Server operating system support is also broad, including FreeBSD, HP/UX, IBM OS/400, Linux, Mac OS X and Solaris.
CommuniGate Pro can also be extended to function as a broad real-time communications platform. The server includes a SIP (Session Initiation Protocol)-based presence engine and an instant messaging server that can be integrated with VOIP phones so that users can use presence data to choose among e-mail, phone and IM-based communications. The IM server supports Microsofts Windows Messenger client.
Next page: Evaluation Shortlist: Related Products.
Page 3
Evaluation Shortlist Bynaris Insight Server 4.2 Offers well-integrated open-source tools but lacks an automated deployment feature (www.bynari.com)
CommuniGate Systems CommuniGate Pro Real-Time Collaboration 4.3 Broadly extensible, with a wide range of groupware features (www.communigate.com)
Gordanos Gordano Messaging Suite 11 Provides a well-integrated suite of messaging tools but is not as extensible as its competitors (www.gordano.com)
IBMs IBM Lotus Domino 6.5 Enterprise groupware with database-driven applications (www.ibm.com)
Microsofts Microsoft Exchange Server 2003 Defines groupware in the Outlook world and allows forms-based applications in Outlook (www.microsoft.com)
Scalixs Scalix Server 9.2.1 Brings good Exchange and Outlook feature fidelity to Linux and Outlook users, with an excellent Web mail interface (www.scalix.com)
Technical Analyst Michael Caton can be reached at michael_caton@ziffdavis.com.
Check out eWEEK.coms for more on IM and other collaboration technologies.